Whistleblowing on The Firm

Tom Cruise starred in the movie “The Firm”.  It is a good portrayal of what can happen to young men seduced by money and power.  The men in suits can appear to be decent, successful and on top of the world.  However, the darker side of corruption hides in backroom deals, manipulation of ethics, ruthlessness and a discarding of those who don’t ‘cut it’.  Some firms go through extensive interview processes to ensure the person has the ‘right values’ to fit into their culture. They will select out the ‘winners’ and promote them through awards and incentives to keep them hooked into the narrative of the story.  It is easy for people overtime to lose themselves in corruption as group think dominates personal gut feeling and it seems ‘normal’, or ‘the way we do things around here’. It is clear not to question the captains of industry, that is not looked upon favourably and your career is over.  The fact there are no contrasting voices (they are removed or moved), it is what makes it psychologically harder to go against the grain.  Human psychology typically wants to fit in as they become stressed if they face opposition.  So those in power make sure they shutdown any internal or external dissent that could shake up the cult like ethos of the organisation.  Loyalty is to smile and agree not to speak up and say what you think.  This is how a cults control.  It runs counter to democratic narratives that are drowned out by ‘business-as-usual’ mantras that regard themselves as serving the greater good.

This is a notable extract from the information.  The question of attorney-client privilege I believe is a real issue as criminality can be hidden.  I wonder how many lawyers would have the courage to break this code in order to serve the public interest?

A more fundamental difference from the book is the motives and manner in which Mitch solves his predicament. In the book, Mitch acknowledges to himself that he is breaking the attorney-client privilege by copying information and giving it to the FBI. In most US states this privilege only applies to crimes that have already been committed. The privilege does not apply if a lawyer knows that his client either is committing or will commit a crime. However, Mitch must disclose information about his legitimate clients as well. Accepting that he will likely not be allowed to practice law anywhere again, he swindles $10 million from the Firm, along with receiving $1 million of a promised $2 million from the FBI for his cooperation. After an extended manhunt involving the police, the firm’s lawyers, and hired thugs from the Morolto family, Mitch escapes with Abby (and his brother Ray) to the Caymans. Before fleeing, he leaves behind detailed records of the firm’s illegal activities, as well as a recorded deposition. Mitch’s information gives federal prosecutors enough evidence to indict half of the Firm’s active lawyers right away, as well as several retired partners. The documents also provide the FBI with circumstantial evidence of the Firm’s involvement in money laundering and tax fraud, and thus probable cause for a search warrant for the firm’s building and files. This additional evidence is enough to smash both the firm and the Morolto family with a massive RICO indictment.

Could you step out of your story and speak the truth?  Could you blow the whistle on people who you thought were friends?  Could you do this at great personal risk?  There are many people in this world who have.  Perhaps that is why some of the excesses didn’t happen and there is still a semblance of democracy, maybe an outline but it still exists in the people.  Life is meant to be a learning journey.  You learn the most when challenged.

Another important issue is representative government of the people.  If regulators are weakened, legislation amended to take away public power, advocacy is not available and political corruption is occuring.  Then this shuts down important avenuess which ensure justice is done (not superficially seen to be done), this then prevents whistleblowers from speaking up in the public interest.  However, this not withstanding should not stop people following what they feel is right for them.  Trust your heart and allow life to guide you.  There are signs and prompts along the way and surprising alliances can occur when visible.

Gandhi would say “truth is still the truth”.  His quote:

“Many people, especially ignorant people, want to punish you for speaking the truth, for being correct, for being you. Never apologize for being correct, or for being years ahead of your time. If you’re right and you know it, speak your mind. Speak your mind. Even if you are a minority of one, the truth is still the truth.”

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Firm_(1993_film)

The Firm (1993 film)

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Not to be confused with The Firm (1989 film) or The Firm (2009 film).

The Firm
Firm ver2.jpg

Theatrical release poster
Directed by Sydney Pollack
Produced by John Davis
Sydney Pollack
Scott Rudin
Screenplay by David Rabe
Robert Towne
David Rayfiel
Based on The Firm
by John Grisham
Starring
Music by Dave Grusin
Cinematography John Seale
Edited by William Steinkamp
Fredric Steinkamp
Production
company
Distributed by Paramount Pictures
Release date
  • June 30, 1993
Running time
154 minutes
Country United States
Language English
Budget $42 million
Box office $270,248,367

The Firm is a 1993 American legal thriller film directed by Sydney Pollack and starring Tom CruiseJeanne TripplehornGene HackmanEd HarrisHolly HunterHal Holbrook and David Strathairn.

The film is based on the 1991 novel The Firm by author John GrishamThe Firm was one of two films released in 1993 that was adapted from a Grisham novel, the other being The Pelican Brief.

Plot

Mitch McDeere (Tom Cruise) is a young man from an impoverished background, but with a promising future as a lawyer. About to graduate from Harvard Law School near the top of his class, he receives a generous job offer from Bendini, Lambert & Locke, a small boutique firm in Memphis specializing in accounting and tax law. He and his wife, Abby (Jeanne Tripplehorn), move to Memphis and Mitch sets to work studying to pass the Tennessee bar exam. Avery Tolar (Gene Hackman), one of the firm’s senior partners, becomes his mentor and begins introducing Mitch to BL&L’s professional culture, which demands complete loyalty, strict confidentiality, and a willingness to charge exceptional fees for their services. Seduced by the money and perks showered on him, including a house and car, he is at first totally oblivious to the more sinister side of his new employer, although Abby has her suspicions.

Mitch passes the bar exam and begins working long hours that put a strain on his marriage. Working closely with Avery, Mitch learns that most of the firm’s work involves helping wealthy clients hide large amounts of money in off-shore shell corporations and other dubious tax-avoidance schemes. While on a trip to the Cayman Islands on behalf of a client, Mitch is seduced by a local woman and cheats on Abby. Unbeknownst to Mitch, this encounter has been arranged by the firm’s sinister security chief, Bill DeVasher (Wilford Brimley), who later uses photos of Mitch’s beach tryst with the woman as blackmail to keep him quiet about the firm’s questionable, even illegal, activities.

Mitch realizes he is now trapped, but after two associates of the firm die under mysterious circumstances, he is approached by FBI agents who inform him that while some of BL&L’s business is legitimate, their biggest client is the Morolto Mafia family from Chicago. The firm’s partners, as well as most of the associates, are all complicit in a massive tax fraud and money-laundering scheme. The two associates who died had learned about the firm’s dark side, and were killed to keep them from talking. The FBI agents warn Mitch that his house, car, and office have probably all been bugged. The FBI pressures Mitch to provide the Bureau with evidence they can use to go after the Moroltos and bring down BL&L.

Mitch knows he faces a stark choice. If he works with the FBI, he believes that even if he stays alive, he will have to disclose information about the firm’s legitimate clients—thus breaking the attorney–client privilege and risking disbarment. However, the FBI warns him that if he stays with the firm, he will almost certainly go to jail when the FBI takes down both the firm and the Moroltos. Either way, his life as he knows it is over, and he agrees to cooperate with the FBI in return for $1.5 million and the release of his imprisoned brother Ray in Arkansas.

Desperate to find a way out, Mitch inadvertently stumbles on a solution when one of his clients complains that he was billed for an extra several hours of fees, as part of the firm’s money-laundering services for the Moroltos. Mailing these padded bills to the firm’s clients is considered to be mail fraud, which would expose the firm to RICO charges. Mitch begins secretly copying the firm’s billing records, but he is unmasked when a prison guard on the Moroltos’ payroll alerts DeVasher after Mitch’s brother Ray is transferred to FBI custody without the usual formalities being followed.

Evading DeVasher and his thugs, Mitch meets with the Morolto brothers and, presenting himself as a loyal attorney looking out for his clients’ best interests, tells them that his contact with the FBI and his copying of the firm’s files were merely an attempt to expose the firm’s illegal overbilling. Mitch asks the Moroltos for permission to turn over their billing invoices in order to help the FBI make their case against the firm. He reveals that he has made his own copies of the files, but assures them that as long as he is alive, any other information he knows about their legal affairs is covered under attorney-client privilege and will never be revealed. Convinced thus, the Moroltos agree to guarantee Mitch’s safety and let him give the FBI all the evidence it needs to prosecute the firm. Since the attorney-client privilege doesn’t apply when a lawyer knows about ongoing criminal activity, Mitch is able to keep his status as a lawyer.

The film ends as the McDeeres leave their house in Memphis and return to Boston, driving the same well-used car in which they arrived in Memphis.

Cast

Production

Gene Hackman‘s name did not appear on the film’s release poster. Hackman joined the film late, when it was already well into production, because the producers had originally wanted to change the gender of the character and cast Meryl Streep, until author John Grisham objected and Hackman was eventually cast. Tom Cruise‘s deal with Paramount already stated that only his name could appear above the title. Hackman also wanted his name to appear above the credits, but when this was refused he asked for his name to be removed completely from the poster.[1] Hackman’s name does appear in the end credits.

This is also the final film for Steven Hill and John Beal.

Principal photography began on November 9, 1992 and ended on March 20, 1993.

The soundtrack is almost exclusively solo piano by Dave Grusin.

Differences from the novel

The film accords with the book in most respects, but the ending is significantly different. Mitch does not end up in the Caribbean, as in the book; he and Abby simply get into their car and drive back to Boston, as the ending narration, “Do you think [the car] will make it?…to Boston?…”

A more fundamental difference from the book is the motives and manner in which Mitch solves his predicament. In the book, Mitch acknowledges to himself that he is breaking the attorney-client privilege by copying information and giving it to the FBI. In most US states this privilege only applies to crimes that have already been committed. The privilege does not apply if a lawyer knows that his client either is committing or will commit a crime. However, Mitch must disclose information about his legitimate clients as well. Accepting that he will likely not be allowed to practice law anywhere again, he swindles $10 million from the Firm, along with receiving $1 million of a promised $2 million from the FBI for his cooperation. After an extended manhunt involving the police, the firm’s lawyers, and hired thugs from the Morolto family, Mitch escapes with Abby (and his brother Ray) to the Caymans. Before fleeing, he leaves behind detailed records of the firm’s illegal activities, as well as a recorded deposition. Mitch’s information gives federal prosecutors enough evidence to indict half of the Firm’s active lawyers right away, as well as several retired partners. The documents also provide the FBI with circumstantial evidence of the Firm’s involvement in money laundering and tax fraud, and thus probable cause for a search warrant for the firm’s building and files. This additional evidence is enough to smash both the firm and the Morolto family with a massive RICO indictment.

In the film, apparently in order to preserve the protagonist’s personal integrity, Mitch exposes a systematic overbilling scheme by the firm, thus driving a wedge between the Moroltos (who in essence become complicit with Mitch) and their law firm (in the book, overbilling only received a brief mention). He receives a smaller amount of money from the FBI, which he gives to Ray, allowing him to disappear. Rather than capitalizing on his circumstances by stealing money from the Firm, as in the book, the movie’s McDeere ends up battered and bruised, but with his integrity and professional ethics intact. Mitch also makes the FBI have to work in order to bring down the firm by having to argue that each instance of excessive billing is a federal offense (by virtue of the excessive bills being sent through the mail). The volume and frequency meets the criteria for RICO, thereby enabling the FBI to effectively put the Firm out of business by seizing its property and equipment and freezing its bank accounts. From here the Moroltos would then need to find another law firm willing to take them on as clients, and if they couldn’t, charges for non-lodgment of tax returns could be brought. Since Mitch is exposing only illegal activity, he is able to retain his law license.

Instead of a BMW, Mitch gets a Mercedes-Benz for joining the firm.

Avery Tolar was originally Avery Tolleson; the latest version of the novel uses the film’s surname. Tolar is portrayed as a sort of reluctant villain in the film, while in the novel he has no such moral conflicts.

The surname of the second man killed on Grand Cayman is Joe Hodges, instead of Hodge as in the novel.

Mitch’s confession to Abby about his sexual infidelity was also unique to the film. In the novel, McDeere never tells Abby about his infidelity. In the book, Abby’s not knowing about Mitch’s infidelity is a major “suspense” piece. Mitch comes home one evening and finds an envelope addressed to Abby, that has “Photos – Do Not Bend” written on it. The photos were surreptitiously given to DeVasher by Art Germain. Mitch thinks it is the pictures he was shown of his infidelity overseas. Abby is in the bedroom when he sees the open package. He enters the bedroom and learns that Abby opened the package, but it was empty. Mitch realizes DeVasher is toying with him, and this incident in the book causes Mitch to cooperate with the FBI. In the film, Mitch’s confession prompts Abby to seriously consider leaving him, but she ultimately helps him bring down the firm.

Also, in the book, Eddie’s old secretary, Tammy, seduces and drugs Avery. In the movie, however, it is Abby who seduces Avery. This also changes the character development because in the movie Abby is portrayed as risking herself for Mitch. In the book, Abby is simply an accomplice to Tammy.

Filming locations

Memphis, Tennessee
  • Elmwood Cemetery – funeral scene
  • Owen Brennan’s – Lunch scene in cocktail/bar area. Owen Brennan’s commemorated the filming by placing plaques on the two cocktail chairs where Tom Cruise and Gene Hackman sat.
  • Peabody Hotel – BBQ roof scene overlooking Mississippi River Bridge and downtown Memphis.
  • Beale Street – Scene where Mitch and Abby see young tumblers as street performers
  • Lausanne Collegiate School – Playground scene and others.
  • Front Street Deli – Meeting at diner.
  • Mud Island
  • Memphis Suspension Railway
  • Blues City Cafe – FBI first meeting with Mitch.
  • Scates Hall, University of Memphis – legal deliberations
Grand CaymanCayman Islands
Marion, Arkansas
  • The Marion Hotel – Apartment room on top floor for a scene.

Release

Critical reception

Critical reaction to The Firm has been mostly positive, with the film earning a 75% rating at Rotten Tomatoes.[2] Audiences polled by CinemaScore gave the film an average grade of “B+” on an A+ to F scale.[3]

Roger Ebert gave The Firm three stars out of four, remarking: “The movie is virtually an anthology of good small character performances. […] The large gallery of characters makes The Firm into a convincing canvas [… but] with a screenplay that developed the story more clearly, this might have been a superior movie, instead of just a good one with some fine performances.”[4]

The film earned some negative reviews as well, notably from James Berardinelli, who said that “[v]ery little of what made the written version so enjoyable has been successfully translated to the screen, and what we’re left with instead is an overly-long [and] pedantic thriller.”[5] Grisham enjoyed the film, remarking: “I thought [Tom Cruise] did a good job. He played the innocent young associate very well.”[6]

Box office

The film was released while Grisham was at the height of his popularity. That week, Grisham and Michael Crichton evenly divided the top six paperback spots on The New York Times Best Seller list.[7] It opened on June 30, 1993 in 2,393 theatres, and landed at #1 at the box office, grossing $25.4 million over the 4th of July weekend. It remained in the #1 spot at the box office for 3 weeks. After 12 weeks in theatres, the film was a huge success, making over $158 million domestically and $111 million internationally ($270 million worldwide).[8][9] Additionally, it was the largest grossing R-rated movie of 1993 and of any film based on a Grisham novel.[10]

Awards

The film earned two Academy Award nominations including Best Supporting Actress for Holly Hunter (losing to Anna Paquin for The Piano, though she did win an Oscar at that year’s ceremony for Best Actress in the same film as Paquin) and Best Original Score for Dave Grusin (losing to John Williams for Schindler’s List).

Home Media

The Firm was released on VHS in December 1993, the cassettes were specially made of blue plastic. The DVD was released on May 23, 2000. The special features include only the teaser and theatrical trailers. The Blu Ray was released on September 11, 2012.

In other media

TV sequel

In April 2011 Entertainment One announced that a sequel to The Firm was being produced with Sony Pictures Television and Paramount Pictures. The series picked up the story of Mitch and his family ten years after the events of the novel and film. The first season was 22 episodes long and began production in Canada in July 2011. In May 2011, NBC confirmed that they had acquired the U.S. broadcast rights to the show and that they planned to début it in January 2012.[11] The show was cancelled after its first season.

References

External links[edit]

Mohandas Gandhi

“God has no religion”

Archives
Categories